That number is obsolete. They changed the design because of all the problems they were having. Here is a direct quote from h-dnet.
(2006) ULYSSES - SEE RECALL BULLETIN
0832 (PART #94483Y)
(2004-06) XB9R, 9S, 9SX, 12R, 12SS
VEHICLES - USE L1167.02A8
(2004-06) XB12SCG LOW - USE L1167.1AE
And it is $67.75 for the one for your bike. Sorry man. Thats just how it goes sometimes when they change the designs.