I don't mean to imply it's unsafe or otherwise, a salvage title would hurt re-sale. I'm just getting a feeling for what it's worth. As long as the tank/frame (with the Vin#) isn't dented, no worries for me.
For instance, I consider 25k fair mileage for an almost decade old bike (2500/year isn't much), but there are many others available with much less, and most people consider that more valuable.
Considering the good:
'09 is the Thunderstorm engine
Ss is nice if you're a bigger rider
99% stock like yours means I don't have to un-do a Youtubers trial and error 'mods'
The extra tire (as long as it hasn't been sitting in the garage for years)
The Bad:
Needs repair. A fork seal job ($400-600) is daunting for most people.
Gotta swap on a new rear tire.
Been down.
Niche bike. Dude, can you still get parts?
Time of year. You think about riding when it's cold and foggy in the SF bay?
I'd throw it on CL for $3000-3500 and be willing to take $2000 after it sits there for a month. Actually, I'd keep it and make time to ride it more, they're awesome!
In My Opinion...